
Dead Poets Society
Dead Poets Society has a great premise and a story worth telling, and I can see why it landed the way it did in its time. Watching it now, though, it does not hold up. The film is cliche and at times cringey, and there were stretches I ended up skipping through.
Robin Williams is excellent, of course. As John Keating, the English teacher who pushes his students to see the world differently, he is a likeable mentor and a great presence in every scene he is in. Ethan Hawke, as the shy Todd Anderson, and Robert Sean Leonard, as Neil Perry, both do fine work. They were relatively unknown at the time and are much bigger names now, but neither stood out to me here.
What kept it from resonating is the casting of the students. They look like grown men playing high schoolers, and that made the poetry readings, the sneaking out at night and the rowdier schoolboy antics hard to buy. At points it was simply a hard watch.
The poems themselves carry a good message, but the film leans on them so heavily that it turns corny. It was a good film for its time, but the years have not been kind to it.