
Shutter Island
One of the greatest plot twists I have seen, and the kind that keeps working after the credits roll.
You spend the rest of the night retelling the story to yourself, going back through the scenes and seeing them differently. That is the mark of a good one. It does not just surprise you, it makes everything before it mean something else. The film plays fair, too. It is all there on a second watch.
The question it leaves you with is the better part. How much did he know about himself, and when, and what does the last line actually mean about the choice he is making. I have gone back and forth on it and I do not think the film wants it settled.
A great performance from Leonardo DiCaprio holds the whole thing up. He has to play a man being two things at once for most of the runtime, without letting you see the seam, and he does it.